tinoesroho wrote:... there's been an upsurge in server users, but not forum users. Why? Some people just want to _play_. Usually the forum represents 10% or so of the userbase.
^ This. A forum is rarely a good gauge of a community at large. There are always many more lurkers than contributors. Fact of life.
One of the issues is community diversity. Minetest speaks to different people in different ways, it attracts a much more varied audience that other games might. This is includes a fairly large age-range differential, which obviously is a huge factor in dealing with different personalities since some personalities aren't even truly "finalized" yet (still lots of maturing to do. But enough about me).
Minetest in general has an uphill struggle to attract new users because of the fact that it will instantly be compared to Mine Craft and the fact is, Minetest isn't anywhere near complete (although "fully" functional); it's still very much in heavy development. That puts a lot of people off. They don't want heavy development, they want little tweaks and shiny new little features. They want a nice little gift wrapped cube... with Mese inside.
As a relative noob, I've found these forums helpful. I think the latest website design is pretty good and lays things out pretty well. Nothing turns a potential user off faster than an inability to find what they need to find e.g. the files, help and information.
I think the Wiki could do with some additional content but if I understand it correctly it's being ported from a previously community-run Wiki? So, I get that this is probably a work in progress.
The only other criticism I would have is that it might be a little tricky getting into (understanding) server games. I played fairly extensively on singleplayer maps before venturing online. When I finally did start playing online, I had no concept of protections and interact privs (Never having played Mine Craft before probably didn't help either). On the plus side, when I got response, I found admin and other players to be helpful.
I've not used IRC so I can't comment on that.
In general, I'd say there's a good base for new users to jump right in to the community. There's a wealth of resources available. AT times, it seems like there's almost too much choice which might be overwhelming for a user (I'm thinking in particular of Mods). So things like forums to try to keep a handle on mods/servers/games etc is a good thing. An actively maintained database would be even better but of course that requires more dedicated time and man-power (at least initially).
On a personal note, I tend to ignore the I'm-leaving-tantrum-posts, as oft amusing as they are.