Page 1 of 1

[Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 04:38
by philipbenr
I noticed that the boats mod is now in minetest_game, and it's thread has been moved to old mods. Also, the parts of the doors mod as well, and the same happened to it.
Now, the title says it all:

Why is there no Farming topic?

I think that this topic would be nice to encourage people to give comments, instead of just posting something that will probably be overlooked in a couple of days. I personally think this a good choice.

And yes, I actually do look in the old mods section.

Just an idea...

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 07:16
by 4aiman
Maybe I've got you wrong, Philip, but:

I think that there might be a sub-sub forum at "bugs&features" sub forum with topics on every single mod in the default game.
The first post may refer to a thread in the "old mods" that would contain the old version of the same mod (in a state prior to adding).

But I've doubts.

I don't think that it's a good idea to move farming (as well as any other widely discussed mod) into old mods, 'cause Adam had stripped his farming before merging to minetest_game.
Therefore, an "old mod" have more functionality than a new one?
And now we have Framing+, Farming++ and all points to a soon appearance of Farming# and Farming##. LOL.
Almost every game tries to re-do farming too.

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 16:52
by rubenwardy
the farming topic was renamed to farming_plus.

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 18:18
by Krock
4aiman wrote:Almost every game tries to re-do farming too.

Well, in my game, I only removed the bronze hoe and added protection support to everything.

rubenwardy wrote:the farming topic was renamed to farming_plus.

Which farming?

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 18:41
by rubenwardy
He is asking why there is no topic for the farming in minetest_game.

viewtopic.php?t=2787

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 20:34
by philipbenr
So if we are to complain/suggest something/feedback in general, then that would be the place to do so?

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 20:40
by rubenwardy
Bugs and problems would be the best place for talking about stuff in Minetest_Game. Or feature discussion.

Re: [Request] Farming Thread

PostPosted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 20:54
by philipbenr
If you read my first post again, I give an explanation of why not.

If not, this is just my opinion. And, just like what Wuzzy did with the character section, I think we should do the same.