Page 1 of 1

Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 03:03
by ZachyGames
It would be good to have minetest in Xbox One and PS4! Also i was going to have Xbox One in my birthday and have the minecraft: Xbox Edition and Tekken 6 or something my birthday is in June.... What do you say? Minetest on Xbox One and PS4?

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 08:07
by rubenwardy
They are both proprietary stores, so I doubt they would like an open source project.

I also doubt Minetest would pass the quality tests. It needs to run for over a day with out crashing due to memory leaks, and they probably want games that are reasonably bug free.

Also, Minetest is a Minecraft clone, and a lot of people are hostile to that.

You can't run a game without it being on the store, due to DRM, AFAIK. Unless you have a development rig.

If this game was in the store, less people would buy Minecraft, meaning Microsoft/Sony lose out on profits.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 15:19
by Jordach
rubenwardy wrote:They are both propriety stores, so I doubt they would like an open source project.

I also doubt Minetest would pass the quality tests. It needs to run for over a day with out crashing due to memory leaks, and they probably want games that are reasonably bug free.

Also, Minetest is a Minecraft clone, and a lot of people are hostile to that.

You can't run a game without it being on the store, due to DRM, AFAIK. Unless you have a development rig.

If this game was in the store, less people would buy Minecraft, meaning Microsoft/Sony lose out on profits.

Fun little factoid: Nintendo loves INDIE. They have little to NONE restrictions, except ~£7 in price. (Which justifies buying the Nintendo license and development for the platform.)

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 17:54
by Calinou
Jordach wrote:[They have little to NONE restrictions, except ~£7 in price. (Which justifies buying the Nintendo license and development for the platform.)


Their SDK probably is proprietary and banishes free/libre games. So, no.

rubenwardy: Minetest is not a Minecraft clone. It would be if the behaviour was exactly the same. Also, the correct spelling is “proprietary”.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 18:12
by rubenwardy
Calinou wrote:
Jordach wrote:[They have little to NONE restrictions, except ~£7 in price. (Which justifies buying the Nintendo license and development for the platform.)


rubenwardy: Minetest is not a Minecraft clone. It would be if the behaviour was exactly the same.


It is a Minecraft clone. The behaviour is very similar.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 18:50
by Achilles
ZachyGames wrote:It would be good to have minetest in Xbox One and PS4! Also i was going to have Xbox One in my birthday and have the minecraft: Xbox Edition and Tekken 6 or something my birthday is in June.... What do you say? Minetest on Xbox One and PS4?


Would be Great :)

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2014 22:27
by gsmanners

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2014 00:44
by stormchaser3000
no because then without proper mod chips, modding would not be posible exept through the mod store. and many people will be disapointed. i also would say that the controlls might be too hard for some people.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2014 00:50
by hoodedice
gsmanners wrote:SteamOS would be greater.

http://store.steampowered.com/livingroom/SteamOS/


We had a discussion on Steam. It is too early, for now. However, both Jordach and I* use steam as a game launcher, and play MT while chatting to our Steam pals.

*Fudge yeah grammar!

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2014 11:30
by Jordach
Well, if you add Minetest into Steam right now, as a non-Steam game, you will get the overlay;

Image

As well as the screenshots library and other cool stuff. But the coolest part would be, say ChainLynx started playing Minetest on a random server, and didn't know which one, I can click that little dropdown, hit join game, and then Minetest will join that server with your usual login details. (Oh god that would be friggin amazing btw)

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2014 14:40
by Calinou
Jordach wrote:But the coolest part would be, say ChainLynx started playing Minetest on a random server, and didn't know which one, I can click that little dropdown, hit join game, and then Minetest will join that server with your usual login details. (Oh god that would be friggin amazing btw)


This isn't going to happen, it needs official Steam implementation.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2014 22:44
by gsmanners
How hard is "official" anything on Steam? I mean, you can play beta software there, already.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Mon May 19, 2014 12:53
by hoodedice
gsmanners wrote:How hard is "official" anything on Steam? I mean, you can play beta software there, already.


To get Minetest onto Steam, you need to get a community greenlight, that is, get a significant number of steam users to agree that Minetest is indeed a game that deserves being on steam. With the general idiotic human race bent on calling MT a ripoff, I don't see this happening anytime in the near future.


And BTW, forget beta. You'd be surprised by the sheer number of broken software on steam, more broken than even Minetest 0.4.9 stable. Ever heard of Ubisoft? Tom Clancy? Ya, their latest free2play is as broken as humpty dumpty when he fell off that dang wall.

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Tue May 20, 2014 12:53
by ZachyGames
I downloaded steam last time... playing team fortress 2 but now i quit steam also i watch stampylonghead sometimes..

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Wed Jun 18, 2014 19:49
by playzooki
it would be awesome if someone ported it to the ps2 lol
probably never going to happen though

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Wed Jun 18, 2014 20:30
by webdesigner97
playzooki wrote:it would be awesome if someone ported it to the ps2 lol
probably never going to happen though

This is an idea I also thought about :D But I cannot compile, my Playstation 2 is not modded and probably the hardware might be a bit too "dusty" ;)

Re: Minetest:Xbox One and PS4 Edition?

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2015 17:22
by Gaming Association
How about a plug and play game for minetest