Modding like Kodu or Scratch

[Neuromancer]

I've started playing around with scratch and Kodu with my kids, and wow this stuff is so cool and easy to use, it allows even non programmers not just to create mods, but whole video games. But what if this kind of modding language was added to Minetest, where users could graphically create mods to Minetest. I know this is way out there, but this really is the future of gaming, where even non programmers can create amazing stuff. Why not Minetest Mods too?

[Evergreen]

I've started playing around with scratch and Kodu with my kids, and wow this stuff is so cool and easy to use, it allows even non programmers not just to create mods, but whole video games. But what if this kind of modding language was added to Minetest, where users could graphically create mods to Minetest. I know this is way out there, but this really is the future of gaming, where even non programmers can create amazing stuff. Why not Minetest Mods too?

Yay scratch! That's how I learned to program. :D

[ch98]

same here! maybe online version will be good

edit: scratch moved online when I checked.

[webdesigner97]

Yep, Scratch is great, but it won' t work for Minetest mods. Scratch and Lua are extremely different, and it would be too much work to start an IDE like Scratch only for Minetets Mods...

[sfan5]

edit: scratch moved online when I checked.

You can still download scratch to your computer

[webdesigner97]

edit: scratch moved online when I checked.

You can still download scratch to your computer

But only version 1.4! The download version of Scratch 2.0 will be published this year, but nobody knows a more exact date :/

[Exilyth]

The largest problem with all graphical interfaces to written languages is that there are always corner cases which can be expressed in the language but not in the graphical representation.

The next largest problem with all graphical interfaces to written languages is that there are always corner cases which can be expressed esily in the language but are hard to express in the graphical representation.


Then again, some sort of minetest mod IDE which lists nodes, craftitems, recipes... as different objects and enables you to modify their metadata with some sort of editor which knows about all the possible existing keys (maybe even depending on which mods are listed as dependencies?) and all the possible existing values the fields can take and allows you to select them from a dropdown menu or add your own (ofc. function members would have to be opened in a text editor w/syntax highlighting & auto complete for maximum customisability) would be nice to have.


Also, scratch is quite nice.

[Evergreen]

edit: scratch moved online when I checked.

You can still download scratch to your computer

But only version 1.4! The download version of Scratch 2.0 will be published this year, but nobody knows a more exact date :/

I personally wish they kept the design of 1.4, it is a lot faster, and I wish they just included the new blocks and features into the existing editor, not a brand new one.

[webdesigner97]

You can still download scratch to your computer

But only version 1.4! The download version of Scratch 2.0 will be published this year, but nobody knows a more exact date :/

I personally wish they kept the design of 1.4, it is a lot faster, and I wish they just included the new blocks and features into the existing editor, not a brand new one.

Well, I think the new GUI is ok, but I didn't create much stuff with it yet. Moving Scratch to the Web is a good idea, also because Cloud Variables were added => Web 2.0

[super_tnt]

I have thought of this myself and I do plan on doing this but I have other projects to complete before this.

Because modding should be open to everyone and modding is a great way to learn about programming.

[Rhys]

Kodu I quit - still good though. And Scratch, cool. Both programs are very nice to play with.