Attachment broken in recent builds

[stu]

entity -> player attachment appears to no longer work in current-dev. I noticed this while making some updates to my wield3d mod, the wield entity seems to vanish when attached to a player.

Sorry I cant give the exact commit that broke it but I suspect may have something to do with the TPV changes, It was last known to be working fine at d753d352f15ac3586a80b42dd4da6aca518c8ec8

[Pavel_S]

In my heli mod there was a trouble when player want to get in heli, and then teleported anyway, or heli dissapear.
I found that it was because of I use "set_attach(parent, "", position, rotation)" instead of "set_attach(parent, "Root", position, rotation)" (also work with any bone and frame).

Also armature looks rotated by engine or blender bug(but actually if it is rotated, player must look to another side ), mesh is OK.

[BlockMen]

I can hardly imagine that this is caused by third person view, since it only "overrides" the animation of players (related to this topic)
Since this commit https://github.com/minetest/minetest/co ... b039c620dd it just "overrides" the animation when player is not attached, but also there should be no influence on attachments.

[stu]

I can hardly imagine that this is caused by third person view, since it only "overrides" the animation of players (related to this topic)
Since this commit https://github.com/minetest/minetest/co ... b039c620dd it just "overrides" the animation when player is not attached, but also there should be no influence on attachments.

I have done some more testing and it turns out that the attachment is not broken after all, it just does not show up for some reason in third person view. Still works in multiplayer though, seems a bit inconsistent all the same.

[BlockMen]

I can hardly imagine that this is caused by third person view, since it only "overrides" the animation of players (related to this topic)
Since this commit https://github.com/minetest/minetest/co ... b039c620dd it just "overrides" the animation when player is not attached, but also there should be no influence on attachments.

I have done some more testing and it turns out that the attachment is not broken after all, it just does not show up for some reason in third person view. Still works in multiplayer though, seems a bit inconsistent all the same.

Ah, right, since MT had no third person view all attachments of your player are hidden. Now that you mention it i remember sapier wants to fix it with pull #1269.

So well, you can call it "introduced by third person view" if you want, although it is just a missing feature for it ;)

[stu]

Ah, right, since MT had no third person view all attachments of your player are hidden. Now that you mention it i remember sapier wants to fix it with pull #1269.

So well, you can call it "introduced by third person view" if you want, although it is just a missing feature for it ;)

No problem, I just hope it is fixed before the next release, thanks.

[stu]

Also armature looks rotated by engine or blender bug(but actually if it is rotated, player must look to another side ), mesh is OK.

This is known about and will probably never be fixed because some mods rely on this 'feature' [citation needed] ;-)
Either rotate your model prior to export or set the attachment rotation to compensate.

[Pavel_S]

... set the attachment rotation to compensate.

I think it`s not fixed yet
viewtopic.php?p=133288#p133288