JavaScript for moddding

[drkwv]

Is there any chance of adding JavaScript as a language used for modding? Programming with Lua is pain. It even doesn't recognize != operator. It blows my mind. I hate Lua. Lua is a bullet that missed it's aim. They wanted simple pretty language but created a freaking brain-eating monster instead.

[kaeza]

This has already been discussed here.

[sfan5]

Please compare Why JavaScript sucks and Why Lua sucks

[BrandonReese]

Use ~= instead of !=

Problem solved

[Evergreen]

No. Just no.

[PilzAdam]

Yea sure, we start recoding thousands of lines of the engine and break every single mod because you want to use != instead of ~=.

[OmniStudent]

Is there any chance of adding JavaScript as a language used for modding? Programming with Lua is pain. It even doesn't recognize != operator. It blows my mind. I hate Lua. Lua is a bullet that missed it's aim. They wanted simple pretty language but created a freaking brain-eating monster instead.

I like your passion :-)

[drkwv]

Yea sure, we start recoding thousands of lines of the engine and break every single mod because you want to use != instead of ~=.

Please compare Why JavaScript sucks and Why Lua sucks

Well, I see the point. But, just to satisfy my curiosity, why not Python then? Does the Python has ever been considered before you decided to choose Lua?

Use ~= instead of !=
Problem solved

No. Just no.

[sfan5]

Yea sure, we start recoding thousands of lines of the engine and break every single mod because you want to use != instead of ~=.

Please compare Why JavaScript sucks and Why Lua sucks

Well, I see the point. But, just to satisfy my curiosity, why not Python then? Does the Python has ever been considered before you decided to choose Lua?

Lua was chosen because it is more lightweight than Python.

[spillz]

I don't think it would be terribly hard to write bindings for python using the Lua api as a starting point. But not clear enough people would use it to make it worthwhile (you and maybe me). And it would fragment development. And as far as i can tell, most devs are happy enough with lua and the ones who aren't probably want c++ mods.

So unless you are interested in maintaining a Javascript or python or whatever port just stick with lua. Code in it for a week and you will adapt well enough.

[philipbenr]

Code in it for a week and you will adapt well enough.

I think that Lua is fine for Minetest, and it is very easy to learn. I did it in one day. (Not very extensively, but hey)...

[Krock]

Code in it for a week and you will adapt well enough.

I think that Lua is fine for Minetest, and it is very easy to learn. I did it in one day. (Not very extensively, but hey)...

Lua is confusing for programmers:
~= instead of !=
no var++ method
indexing starts at 1 instead of 0
everything is just one type of variable. my first try to define a string

Your phone or window isn't wide enough to display the code box. If it's a phone, try rotating it to landscape mode.

Code: Select all

string test = "Hello world";

[Kilarin]

Lua is confusing for programmers

Every programming language is a little different. I've worked in Java, C, PRPC, COBOL, VB, Assembler, Pascal, Javascript, Notetab Clips, Jython, and probably at least 8 different forms of Basic. If Lua began it's indexing at 0 instead of 1 it would be confusing to programmers from a different background.

What's tripping me up the most is Lua's requirement for a "then" on an if. But when I first switched from primarily programming in Pascal to primarily programming in Java, it was the LACK of a "then" that confused me. Every programming language has it's individual quirks.

As for everything being one type of variable, yeah, it is still taking me a while to get used to that, but that is one of Lua's strengths. It is designed to be a scripting language that works easily when interacting with just about any other parent language. Because Lua's variables are not strongly typed, they are VERY flexible.

Lua is simple and obvious enough that even non-programmers can work in it pretty quickly with just a few examples.

[rubenwardy]

I wouldn't like vanilla Javascript to be used for modding. However, Google makes a version which has classes, and it is open source.

It is best to keep with Lua, though.

[philipbenr]

It is best to keep with Lua, though.

I second that.

[rubenwardy]

It is best to keep with Lua, though.

I second that.

The reason I say that is not because it is any better (I don't really have an opinion on that), but because it would be a PITA to modify the engine to either:

• Add multiple languages
• Switch to JavaScript.

[philipbenr]

Plus, adding more languages would make things more complex, make the engine heavier, and take up much more space.

[JPRuehmann]

Hi
<sarcasm>Java script is a pain in th as to! let us use bash.</sarcasm>
have Fun,
JPR

[sfan5]

Code in it for a week and you will adapt well enough.

I think that Lua is fine for Minetest, and it is very easy to learn. I did it in one day. (Not very extensively, but hey)...

Lua is confusing for programmers:
~= instead of !=
no var++ method
indexing starts at 1 instead of 0
everything is just one type of variable. my first try to define a string

Your phone or window isn't wide enough to display the code box. If it's a phone, try rotating it to landscape mode.

Code: Select all

string test = "Hello world";

C++ is confusing for programmers:
!= instead of ~=
WTF does var++ do?
indexing starts at 0 instead of 1
every variable needs to have types. my first try to define a string

Your phone or window isn't wide enough to display the code box. If it's a phone, try rotating it to landscape mode.

Code: Select all

test = "Hello world"

Do you notice something?

[HeroOfTheWinds]

The back-and-forth in this thread is making me split my sides in laughter. But seriously.

It's true: every language has its quirks. I started in Python, but then moved to Visual Basic, and couldn't wrap my head around the reason they make you say "dim" before declaring variables. Every language is going to have something that someone doesn't like, and that's not restricted to programming languages either. It just has to be dealt with and move on. I didn't like lua at first either, but I got used to it, and now I'm attempting to code things that I consider pretty neat. I wouldn't go using Lua to program the next Legend of Zelda, but it certainly gets the job done for a lightweight language to code mods for Minetest.

If you really despise Lua that much, do this, which I'm sure you'll find even less agreeable: Code a program that lets you write a mod in JavaScript, and then have that program convert your JS code to Lua automatically. Problem solved, everybody happy. (If you're an optimist.)

[kaeza]

everything is just one type of variable

Lua is a dynamically typed language. This means that variables do not have types; only values do. There are no type definitions in the language. All values carry their own type.

[aldobr]

I write my own programming languages for breakfest.

Lua is ok.

Real programmers (TM) can use any turing complete language, period.

[D0431791]

+1. I think somebody will branch Minetest and implement a javascript Modding System.

[rubenwardy]

+1. Somebody will branch Minetest and implement a javascript Modding System.

Why the guarantee?